JANUARY 1999 
 
 

 
 
Gianfranco Malafarina
A world of tramps and scoundrels, miserable and beggars, wanderers and mendicants, meets us in these days at Brescia. Third world outcasts knocking at the Padania welfare ? Or the recall of the helpful ladies toward the needs of the underprivileged? Nothing at all. The unbecoming and yelling mob, ragged and coarse, that meets us in the recently renewed halls of the Santa Giulia Museum, is the theme of the first extensive exhibition dedicated to an underestimated for a long time painting genre, the painting with genre scenes, precisely, or better, in this specific extent, that trend, fascinating and still unexplored, dedicated to the most humble and popular aspect of reality. A trend that had great successful in Italy between the XVII and the XVIII century and that boasts, besides few known masters, properly reassessed just this occasion, masterpieces of Caravaggio, Salvator Rosa, Alessandro Magnasco, Giuseppe Maria Crespi, Gaspare Traversi. 
Giovan Battista Carlone "The tramps company" (first half '600) Private collection 

Giuseppe Gambarini "Winter allegory " (first half '700) Bologna, National picture gallery 

Giovanni Michele Graneri "Market scene" (first half '700) Private collection 

Bernardo Strozzi "The cook " (half '600) Genova, Red Palace Gallery 

Giacomo Ceruti "Working women " (first half '700) Brescia, Civic Museums

 

  Ideated by Francesco Porzio and the late Federico Zeri, the exhibition is not limited nevertheless to line up a series of exceptional paintings about the theme of pauperism and lower classes, but gives a very high level framing not only by the point of view of history and art but also a wider historical and sociological key. Even if looked at with a certain mistrust by the professional historians, the figurative text is in fact an extraordinary instrument of knowledge and learning, and often offers about a world, an age or a society, more enlightening data than any reconstruction carried out by the means of dusty archive documents . So this humble and poor human being talks to us meaningfully, and in terms still very actual, about the relationship between high and low culture , the behaviour of the affluent classes toward the world of the underprivileged, about the way the attention to derelicts evolves from a generic interpretation, carnival and caricature kind, toward an ambivalent feeling, of repugnance and irony, fear and pity to finally flow into a substantial acceptance of the human dignity of the poor and into a more sharing description of their real life conditions. The exposition of Brescia records all the stages of this evolution starting from the sixteenth-century precedents, wherein the attention to the popular themes makes its way beside the traditional religious iconography finally relegating it in a second row, and finishing with Giacomo Ceruti, the great eighteenth century painter, Milanese by birth but who grew at Brescia , able to give complete autonomy and truth to the poor world “. With Ceruti, the so called 'genre' painting, that still at the Caravaggio's times were considered inferior as regards to the religious and historical painting, appears already without comic, grotesque or moralising features and with his clear and pure adhesion to the humbles world he opens the door to the modern realism.