|
George Gilles de la Tourette, Charcot's pupil at the
Salpétrière Hospital, Paris, defined Tourette's Syndrome, the pathological
condition that has carried his name since 1885. Characterized by multiple
tics of diverse nature, the disease had already been described by Dr.
Itard in 1825
The syndrome is diagnostic (as per the DSM IV) when the patient presents:
motor tics varying in intensity
and involving diverse regions;
vocal and/or sound tics;
fixed ideas leading to related
tics (repetitive ideas with the impulse to carry them out or the obsession
to perform certain unjustified behavioural patterns).
Epidemiologically speaking Tourette's Syndrome prevails in 4-5 individuals
on 10,000 in the population at large. The disease's motor symptoms can
generally be noticed within the first 7 years of life, while vocal tics
set in around the age of 11. The disorder's incidence is three times higher
in males than in females. From an aetiopathogenetic viewpoint genetic
factors no doubt play a decisive role in the development of Tourette's
Syndrome, though details have still to be defined. Tourette's Syndrome
and the Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder are closely related; the latter
was in fact noticed in 40% of Tourette patients. But the syndrome's relations
with the Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is even more interesting
as about 50% of patients suffering from the latter present both problems.
The dopaminergic system's involvement in tic disorders has been ascertained,
and this explains how dopamine antagonist drugs (i.e. haloperidol, pimozide
and flufenazine) diminish tic intensity, while agents that increase central
dopaminergic activity (i.e. methylphenidate, amphetamines, pemoline and
cocaine) instead tend to aggravate them. But anomalies in the noradrenergic
system, such as diminished tic intensity resulting from the administration
of clonidine (an alpha-adrenergic agonist that reduces the release of
noradrenaline in the CNS), have been noticed, thus confirming the theory
of neurotransmitter alterations in the disorder's aetiopathogenesis. Organic
lesions in basal ganglia cause many movement disorders like Huntington's
Disease, the Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder and the Attention Deficit Hyperactivity
Disorder. From an organic viewpoint Tourette's Syndrome seems to originate
at this level. Recent studies suggest that certain forms of Tourette's
Disease are caused by an autoimmune response directed against basal ganglia
and triggered by Streptococcus beta-haemolyticus group A infections. Other
clinical evidence has proved relations between Tourette's Syndrome and
Borrelia burgdorferi infections (Lyme's disease). A proper diagnosis requires
the disease to appear before the patient is 18 years old (generally around
5-6 years) and it must neither result from the direct physiological effects
of a substance (i.e. stimulants) nor from a general medical condition
(i.e. Huntington's disease or viral encephalitis). The most frequent initial
symptom is a blinking tic (blepharospasm), followed at a later date by
abnormal head movements, such as grimaces. Tics tend to present a rostro-caudal
progression in time, involving other body regions too. Three forms of
Tourette's Syndrome are currently classified: 1. the pure form, which
only presents motor and vocal tics; 2. the complex form, which, besides
motor and vocal tics, also involves copropraxia, coprolalia, echolalia,
etc.; 3. the plus form, which combines the above described symptoms with
the Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, or rather with obsessive-compulsive
disorders. Treatment is chiefly pharmacological, though the medication
(in a broad sense) of Tourette patients presents quite a few problems,
mainly the answers to questions concerning which patients must be treated,
the treatment method and its duration. The syndrome in question is too
diversified concerning both the clinical picture and compromised physiopathology.
Hence the therapeutic problem cannot be 'summarily' solved. Every patient
is a case in itself and the clinical picture, by definition based on syndromes,
is changeable! We must consider that in the DSM IV classification Tourette's
Syndrome also involves social embarrassment and this factor, before all
else and beyond diagnostic aspects, should motivate us to begin any medication
whatsoever once the disease has been recognized with its subsequent embarrassment.
It is understood that the mildest TS pictures require no treatment whatsoever.
Those associated with ADHD that could present educational and working
difficulties are an exception. OCD pictures are often inadequately compensated
and are a factor of disorder in daily life. However, as already mentioned,
neurological drugs remain the basic medication for Tourette's Syndrome.
Drugs that are effective on the dopaminergic systems are the core of the
therapeutic approach. In fact neuroleptics play a leading role in the
treatment of Tourette patients' symptoms: haloperidol is successfully
combined with pimozide, which, like other D2 receptor specific neuroleptics,
presents more or less acceptable collateral effects that must however
be monitored. Patients treated with pimozide can in fact present ECG alterations;
accurate cardiologic follow ups are hence required. Sulpiride, tiapride
and, recently, risperidone (atypical neuroleptics) are used with fair
results. Table 3 reports the receptor profile and D2 receptor bonds formed
in the striated muscle with neuroleptics that can be used in Tourette's
Syndrome. Results are variable and at times unforeseeable; worse still,
these drugs have a limited duration as they lose their effectiveness in
time. To date there are neither papers nor predictive clinical signs that
advice the clinician to use a certain neuroleptic drug instead of another.
Besides no currently available controlled clinical studies have systematically
faced this issue.
|
|
Olanzapine (an atypical neuroleptic marketed quite recently
in Italy) is frequently resorted to for clinical use. Data concerning
the use of tetrabenazine, a powerful dopaminergic depleter, is no doubt
interesting, though the drug is hard to find in Italy as it is not registered
in our country. Dopamine agonists (34) such as pergolide and similar drugs
have an entirely opposite use in terms of pathogenetic assumptions, compared
to neuroleptics, but this only confirms the complex systems involved in
the disease's progress. Clonidine's, an alpha-2 adrenergic agonist, recent
use has been successful and so has guanfacine's use. Stimulating psychotropic
drugs, like methylphenidate and amphetamines, have proved useful (28-29-30-36)
in disorders caused by ADHD, while drugs that act selectively on serotonin
reuptake (SSRI) seem in some way useful in obsessive-compulsive conditions.
Table 4 reports drugs in use and their initial dosage for the various
clinical aspects of Tourette's Syndrome. Dosages must however be adapted
case by case. Interesting data has been recently published concerning
the use of nicotine, also administered in the form of nicotine patches,
often combined with neuroleptics, whose dosage can be reduced, as there
are synergies between nicotine and dopaminergic receptors. Systemic drugs
can be used along with avant-garde therapies like the Botulinum toxin
used in the local treatment of muscle districts involved in the various
pathological movements. The toxin relaxes muscles, which subsequently
"move" less, but the relaxation also reduces proprioception with a subsequent
reduced sensitive "feeling", which is often the first sign of fits of
pathological movements (premonitory sensation). This method enables the
infiltration of vocal cords, which are percutaneously injected and electromyographically
monitored, with small doses of Botulinum toxin to modify the proprioception
that detects muscle tension, thus reducing coprolalic "fits" or, generally
speaking, reducing the vocalization or emission of pathological sounds.
The Author has treated a series of patients by infiltrating their vocal
cords, reached percutaneously with the method described by Scott et al.,
with Botulinum A toxin. Results obtained are to date highly satisfactory.
|
|
The only collateral effect is a transitory 85-90% loss
of voice in the cases treated. Antibiotics are rarely required and only
when a high antistreptolysin titre reveals a streptococcal infection.
Plasmapheresis and immunoglobulins have been resorted to on the basis
of the immunological premises described above. Stereotaxic neurosurgery,
chiefly based on the stimulation of certain brain districts, hence non-invasive
surgery, has been resorted to in some cases of Tourette's Syndrome and
serious OCDs. Psychiatric and psychodynamic treatments are currently resorted
to, though they present alternate results. They often back up psychotherapies,
which make this disorder that greatly alters the individuals' and their
families' quality of life, more bearable. It is a fact that the disease
must also be studied outside the neurological sphere, if only to better
understand the use of drugs that often do not consider Tourette's Syndrome
among the indications recorded.
Conclusions
Tourette's Syndrome has recently been extensively "revisited",
with subsequent changes in its psychopathological picture and management.
The disease has been withdrawn from the list of extrapyramidal disorders
and it has been moved from the sole psychiatric field to a neurological
one and more besides. Epidemiology itself reveals the disorder's social
relevance, considering its incidence; hence Tourette's Syndrome can no
longer be considered an "orphan disease". Precise guide-lines are now
being defined both from a diagnostic and therapeutic perspective. In the
light of the brief considerations made herein too, the disorder's management
and diagnostic approach have many facets that touch on neurology and psychology,
psychiatry and sociology. Only close attention paid to the conditions
presented by Tourette patients can change the quality of life of a relevant
number of mostly young individuals, who are at times in serious conditions
of discomfort. The above described drugs are therapeutically essential:
their detailed knowledge is now necessary, though most have yet to be
recognized by the Italian Ministry of Health as recommended for use in
Tourette's Syndrome.
|